High Time in the High Sierra

by Jared Smith

 

Every September after Labor Day, stillness descends upon the Bishop Creek Canyon.  The kids are back in school, the family vacations have come and gone and the hustle and bustle of the summertime gives way to the peace and quiet of fall. It is during this time that serious trout anglers, the ones who are really in the know, head for the high country. Mild days, crisp cool evenings, light crowds, gorgeous fall colors and exceptional trout fishing are dead giveaways that autumn has arrived. Still, it’s safe to say that vast majority of area visitors miss out on what I consider to be hands down the best time of the year in the High Sierra.

 
 

Scenic North Lake is a favorite destination for float tubers”  

        So, you may be asking yourself what’s so great about the fall. Well, there are lots of reasons that September and October are exceptional but the biggest reason is pretty simple really…just as many fish, a fraction of the people. You see the California Department of Fish and Game continues to stock South Lake, Lake Sabrina, North Lake, Intake II, Weir Pond and both forks of Bishop Creek all the way through October. With the light fall crowds, there are just more fish per rod out there to catch and a lot less anglers to compete with.

 

“Parchers Resort owner Judy Smith displaying a healthy 6lb rainbow

 caught at South Lake using a mini-jig”

 

Wild Trout Time

The top picks for wild trout in the fall are South Lake and Lake Sabrina. In addition to the stocked Rainbows, both of these waters have solid populations of wild Brown and Brook Trout. While these wild species of trout are occasionally caught during the summer months, both Browns and Brookies are fall spawners which makes them far easier to find and catch during this time.

“I like fall fishing because the Browns start to come up” said Rick Apted of Lake Sabrina Boat Landing. When asked where anglers should go to find these pre-spawn Browns, Rick suggested finding areas of the lake that have a sandy bottom, especially sandy areas near the inlets. The Browns at Sabrina tend to stage in these areas just prior to spawning. Natural baits like crickets, nightcrawlers and mealworms are especially effective during the pre-spawn period. The other favorite tactic in the fall is slow trolling lures that imitate small trout such as Rapalas or large Kastmasters.  When trolling, especially when targeting Browns, it’s a good idea to use a technique referred to as “ripping”. Instead of just sitting back with your rod in the holder and slowly trolling your lure, hold your rod in your hand and every few seconds give your lure a big jerk and then let the lure drift back. The sporadic action this puts on the lure makes it look a lot more like an injured fish, the favorite meal of the trophy Brown Trout.

At South Lake the Long, Treasure and Gilbert Glacier inlets are the places to find the Browns in the early fall. As October approaches, especially during low water years, the water level drops and can expose the lake bottom of the back part of the lake. When this happens the three main inlets to the lake actually meander through this flat area and form one inlet that dumps into the main body of the lake near the front of the island. It is during this time that the Browns and Brookies have absolutely perfect spawning habitat. I’ve been back there in the fall and seen pools that literally have hundreds of fish in them, and every single fish is a Brown or Brookie. As the fish move into the inlet streams during the spawn, the trout are not actively feeding so the idea is more to cause a reaction strike than it is to present something that a hungry fish would want to eat. Spinners like Panther Martins and Mepps are perfect for this situation and the flashing spinning blades really annoy a spawning trout.

Backcountry fishing in the fall is also worth a try with over fifty lakes within day hike range in the Bishop Creek Drainage. “Folks sometimes forget about Long Lake in the fall but its one of the best backcountry lakes to fish during the autumn months as the Browns get ready to spawn” said Gary Olsen of Bishop Creek Lodge. He suggests fishing nightcrawlers or Brook Trout pattern CD7 rapalas near the inlets at Long Lake.

The majority of the Browns found in the Bishop Creek area are in the 10" to 14" range, but there are some monsters lurking in the depths. The lake record fish at Lake Sabrina is a whopping 15lbs 12oz and the South Lake record is 17lbs 1oz, both incredible catches.  Lake Sabrina Boat Landing and South Lake Landing offer boat and kayak rentals as well as a selection of tackle, bait, clothing, snacks, drinks, souvenirs and Sabrina even has a café.

 

 

 Majestic South Lake produces lots of trophy rainbows every fall”

 

Prime Creek Fishing

Although the still water fishing in the canyon is certainly epic, the creek fishing is not to be passed up.  Some folks don’t realize it but there are nearly 20 miles of fishable stream in the Bishop Creek Canyon. It is also true that most area visitors fish the creek during the summer months when snow runoff is at its highest and creek flows are really ripping. Fishing is great in the summer but in the fall, after the snow has mostly melted, creek flows are reduced leaving more fishable pools for anglers to enjoy. During the summer, fast water can make certain stretches of stream difficult or even impossible to fish, even if those stretches are loaded with trout. Once the creek slows down a bit though, those fish are a whole lot easier to get at and it shows in the fish counts.  “The fact that there are hardly any people fishing the streams in the fall makes it a great time of year to be hitting Bishop Creek” said Ron Scira of Creekside RV Park.  He went on to say that “I’ve noticed that natural baits like nightcrawlers are better than powerbait during the fall”.  While natural baits seem to win out in the fall for bait anglers, the artificial baits that are effective during the summer work just as well in the fall. Mini-jigs, trout worms and Panther Martins are very dependable lures.

 

South Lake regular Tim Carnahan displaying a beautiful fall rainbow

 

“Quality Brown Trout like this 3-1/4lb beauty caught by  

“Fish Story Lori” Carnahan at Lake Sabrina can be found throughout the Bishop Drainage.”

 

Trophy Time

The fall is hands down the best time to catch one of the trophy rainbows that the Bishop Creek Canyon is famous for. All summer long, Alpers are planted in area lakes and streams and while some of those fish are caught, several out of every stocking aren’t caught. This means that the number of big fish gets larger and larger as the season goes on. When the crisp autumn nights bring the water temps down, the fish know that winter will be here before long and not surprisingly, they get very aggressive trying to score as many meals as they can before the snow flies. So there are more big fish and they’re more active…sounds like a recipe for trophy time doesn’t it?

How to fool the big one varies to some degree depending on what kind of fishing you prefer and where you want to go. In the streams, it’s all about timing and a little luck. The creek fish, even the big ones, eat the same stuff as the small ones so being in the right place at the right time is the key factor. Something to consider is that the majority of the large trout in the streams are stocked fish, most of them courtesy of Adopt-A-Creek, a non-profit organization dedicated to enhancing the fisheries of Bishop Creek, Intake II and North Lake. The fish are typically put into the streams near campgrounds and where the creek crosses or comes near to the road. In my experience, these fish tend to stay relatively close to where they are stocked so that is something to consider. One might think that the big one is in a hard to reach hole way up or down stream from the campgrounds but that doesn’t seem to hold true.

In the lakes, what you’re using is crucial as certain techniques tend to select big fish. At the top of this list are plastics, namely mini-jigs like Trout Traps or Trout Teasers and trout worms like Lip Ripperz, Berkley Powerworms or Gulp! Trout worms. During our four years operating South Lake Landing, the number of trout weighing 3lbs or better  that have been caught on plastics is far more than the number of fish caught on all other lures and baits combined, even though the folks using plastics are in the minority. Plastics are simply the best way to catch big fish in the fall. The hot colors change somewhat from year to year but with mini-jigs you’re almost always safe with are pearl white and dark brown colors like pumpkinseed.  For plastic trout worms the best colors are bright colors like orange, pink and yellow. Aside from plastics, streamers like Olive Wooly Buggers are an excellent choice for fooling a big ‘bow, especially in mid September. For South Lake and Sabrina, fishing from a boat and being able to move from spot to spot is a huge advantage over fishing from shore.  Float tubers also have the advantage of mobility but it’s somewhat of a long kick to the best areas on the bigger lakes so most of the tubers prefer to chase the trophy trout of a lifetime at North Lake and Intake II, two smaller lakes with excellent shore access.

 

My Favorite Time….

        While the fishing alone makes a late season visit to the Bishop Creek Canyon worth the trip, there is so much more to it than that. It’s the friendly faces of the other folks lucky enough to have chosen the fall as their time to visit the canyon. It’s the scenery, the serenity, the sound of an autumn breeze shaking the aspens as it blows through the canyon…it’s perfect. It’s my favorite time to be here. It’s the time of year that reminds me just how outrageously lucky we all are to be able to visit this place, for an afternoon, for a day, for a week. It’s the time of year when there is literally a postcard quality view in every direction and you simply can’t be here without being humbled by the grandeur of it all. Fall is the time….high time in the High Sierra.

 

For more information on visiting the Bishop Creek Canyon, please contact these fine local businesses.

Parchers Resort & South Lake Landing
(760)873-4177
www.ParchersResort.net

Bishop Creek Lodge
(760) 873-4484
www.BishopCreekResort.com

Cardinal Village
(760) 873-4789
www.CardinalVillageResort.com

Creekside RV Park
(760) 873-4483
www.BishopCreeksideRVPark.com

Lake Sabrina Boat Landing
(760) 873-7425
www.LakeSabrinaBoatLanding.com